Rent vs buy break-even
Free rent vs buy calculator-compare net worth, opportunity cost, and break-even year with taxes, insurance, maintenance, and closing costs.
Rent vs Buy Calculator
Horizon presets (stay length / move timing)
Property
Down payment presets (low down may include PMI)
Loan
Illustrative rates by credit range for planning only. Not a quote, pre-approval, or credit pull. Edit the rate to match a real offer.
Ownership Costs
≈ $292/mo at today’s price
These are state average estimates only. Actual taxes, insurance, and PMI vary by county, credit score, LTV, home characteristics, and insurer. Not a quote.
Transaction Costs
≈ $7,000 at purchase
Applied if you sell at the end of the horizon
Renting looks stronger
$39,573
after 7 years
Break-even year: does not break even within 7 years
Renting looks stronger by $39,573 after 7 years
Break-even year: does not break even within 7 years
$152,608
$192,181
Year-1 monthly housing
- Principal & Interest$1,770
- Property Tax$306
- Home Insurance$190
- Maintenance$292
P&I $1,770/mo
- Rent$1,800
- Renters Insurance$20
Buy is $738 higher /mo in year 1
At year 7
Home value
$431,674
Mortgage left
$253,165
Equity (pre-sale)
$178,509
Net sale proceeds
$152,609
Buy portfolio
$0
Rent portfolio
$192,181
Sale assumes selling costs of $25,900. Initial capital invested on the rent path: $77,000 (down payment + buy closing). Lifetime housing cash (excl. sale): buy $217,619, rent $167,189.
Educational estimates only. Does not include tax benefits, variable rates, or investment guarantees. Not a loan offer or financial advice.
See our other calculators
Explore more educational finance tools from FinanceFlow.
- Estimate payments with taxes and insurance, PMI, extra payments, and amortization.Mortgage Payment Calculator Estimate payments with taxes and insurance, PMI, extra payments, and amortization.
- Compare payments, estimate break-even months, and model cash-out refinance equity.Refinance Break-Even Calculator Compare payments, estimate break-even months, and model cash-out refinance equity.
- Estimate max home price from income, debts, and 28/36 DTI guidelines.How Much House Can I Afford Estimate max home price from income, debts, and 28/36 DTI guidelines.
- How much can I borrow with a HELOC? Credit limit, CLTV, and payments.HELOC Calculator How much can I borrow with a HELOC? Credit limit, CLTV, and payments.
- Monthly car payment, amount financed with trade-in and tax, extras, and amortization.Car Loan Payment Calculator Monthly car payment, amount financed with trade-in and tax, extras, and amortization.
- Max vehicle price from monthly payment or income, with trade-in, tax, and fees.How Much Car Can I Afford Max vehicle price from monthly payment or income, with trade-in, tax, and fees.
- Quick screen: home price ÷ annual rent, educational bands, and the 5% rule.Price to Rent Ratio Calculator Quick screen: home price ÷ annual rent, educational bands, and the 5% rule.
Rent vs buy guide
Break-even year, cost stack, time horizons, and first-time buyer scenarios-how to use this educational tool.
Break-even year: when buying may pull ahead
This rent vs buy break-even calculator shows the first year in your horizon when estimated buy net worth is at least as high as rent net worth. That is not the same as “monthly cash flow is lower”-it includes equity, sale costs at the horizon, and opportunity cost of capital. Use the break-even label in the results panel as your decision timeline under your assumptions.
What’s included in the total cost comparison
Buy-side costs can include principal and interest, property tax, homeowners insurance, HOA, conventional PMI (when LTV is above 80%), maintenance, buy closing costs, and selling costs at the end of the horizon. Rent-side costs include rent with growth, renters insurance, and optional fees. That stack supports long-tails like “with taxes and insurance,” “including maintenance,” and “with closing costs” on one transparent model.
Time horizon: 3, 5, 7, and 10 years
If you might move in 3 years, a short horizon often favors renting once transaction costs and opportunity cost are counted. Staying 7–10 years can change the break-even year if equity and appreciation build. Use the horizon preset chips (or ?horizon=5 in the URL) to stress-test stay length without inventing separate pages for each year.
Opportunity cost of the down payment
Cash used for a down payment and closing costs is not invested on the buy path at purchase. The rent path invests that capital at your assumed return. Raise or lower investment return to see how sensitive the verdict is-this is a core reason simple “rent vs payment” comparisons can mislead.
First-time buyers, low down payment, and PMI
Try 5% or 10% down with the presets. On Conventional loans, PMI can appear when LTV is above 80%, raising year-1 buy housing cost. Pair a low down payment with a realistic horizon if you may relocate. For “how much house can I afford,” use the affordability calculator; for payment detail with taxes and insurance, use the mortgage payment calculator.
Price-to-rent ratio and the 5% rule
Rules of thumb (price ÷ annual rent, or ~5% of price per year as a crude ownership cost) are useful screens, not full decisions. They ignore financing, opportunity cost, appreciation, and how long you stay-exactly what this net-worth model is built to explore. For a dedicated screen, use the price to rent ratio calculator, then come back here for break-even year and net worth.
Rent vs buy with different credit score rates
Credit score ranges preset an illustrative mortgage rate on the buy path only. Higher rates raise ownership cost and can push break-even later; lower rates help buying. Combine with horizon presets when you search for rent vs buy calculator scenarios. Example: /rent-vs-buy?credit=good&horizon=7 . No credit pull—educational estimates only.
Rent vs buy FAQ
Break-even, stay length, costs included, opportunity cost, and more.