Rent vs buy break-even

Free rent vs buy calculator-compare net worth, opportunity cost, and break-even year with taxes, insurance, maintenance, and closing costs.

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Time & Assumptions
Planning horizon and the return you might earn on cash not put into a home. Use presets for 3–10 year stay scenarios.

Horizon presets (stay length / move timing)

years
If You Buy
Purchase price, loan, ownership costs, appreciation, and transaction costs

Property

USD

Down payment presets (low down may include PMI)

USD

Loan

Credit score range Illustrative as of 2026-07

Illustrative rates by credit range for planning only. Not a quote, pre-approval, or credit pull. Edit the rate to match a real offer.

Loan amount · LTV$280,000 · 80.0%

Ownership Costs

/mo
/mo
/mo
/mo

≈ $292/mo at today’s price

These are state average estimates only. Actual taxes, insurance, and PMI vary by county, credit score, LTV, home characteristics, and insurer. Not a quote.

Transaction Costs

≈ $7,000 at purchase

Applied if you sell at the end of the horizon

Comparison
Educational net-worth estimate after 7 years—not financial advice

Renting looks stronger

$39,573

after 7 years

Break-even year: does not break even within 7 years

$152,608

$192,181

Difference (buy − rent)-$39,573

Year-1 monthly housing

Buy$2,558
  • Principal & Interest$1,770
  • Property Tax$306
  • Home Insurance$190
  • Maintenance$292

P&I $1,770/mo

Rent$1,820
  • Rent$1,800
  • Renters Insurance$20

Buy is $738 higher /mo in year 1

At year 7

Home value

$431,674

Mortgage left

$253,165

Equity (pre-sale)

$178,509

Net sale proceeds

$152,609

Buy portfolio

$0

Rent portfolio

$192,181

Sale assumes selling costs of $25,900. Initial capital invested on the rent path: $77,000 (down payment + buy closing). Lifetime housing cash (excl. sale): buy $217,619, rent $167,189.

Educational estimates only. Does not include tax benefits, variable rates, or investment guarantees. Not a loan offer or financial advice.

If You Rent
Rent, growth, and other monthly rental costs
/mo
/mo
/mo
Net Worth Over Time
Buy vs rent estimated net worth at the end of each year (sale assumed each year for a fair cash comparison)
Loading chart…
Yearly Detail
Housing paid, equity, and net worth by year

See our other calculators

Explore more educational finance tools from FinanceFlow.

Rent vs buy guide

Break-even year, cost stack, time horizons, and first-time buyer scenarios-how to use this educational tool.

Break-even year: when buying may pull ahead

This rent vs buy break-even calculator shows the first year in your horizon when estimated buy net worth is at least as high as rent net worth. That is not the same as “monthly cash flow is lower”-it includes equity, sale costs at the horizon, and opportunity cost of capital. Use the break-even label in the results panel as your decision timeline under your assumptions.

What’s included in the total cost comparison

Buy-side costs can include principal and interest, property tax, homeowners insurance, HOA, conventional PMI (when LTV is above 80%), maintenance, buy closing costs, and selling costs at the end of the horizon. Rent-side costs include rent with growth, renters insurance, and optional fees. That stack supports long-tails like “with taxes and insurance,” “including maintenance,” and “with closing costs” on one transparent model.

Time horizon: 3, 5, 7, and 10 years

If you might move in 3 years, a short horizon often favors renting once transaction costs and opportunity cost are counted. Staying 7–10 years can change the break-even year if equity and appreciation build. Use the horizon preset chips (or ?horizon=5 in the URL) to stress-test stay length without inventing separate pages for each year.

Opportunity cost of the down payment

Cash used for a down payment and closing costs is not invested on the buy path at purchase. The rent path invests that capital at your assumed return. Raise or lower investment return to see how sensitive the verdict is-this is a core reason simple “rent vs payment” comparisons can mislead.

First-time buyers, low down payment, and PMI

Try 5% or 10% down with the presets. On Conventional loans, PMI can appear when LTV is above 80%, raising year-1 buy housing cost. Pair a low down payment with a realistic horizon if you may relocate. For “how much house can I afford,” use the affordability calculator; for payment detail with taxes and insurance, use the mortgage payment calculator.

Price-to-rent ratio and the 5% rule

Rules of thumb (price ÷ annual rent, or ~5% of price per year as a crude ownership cost) are useful screens, not full decisions. They ignore financing, opportunity cost, appreciation, and how long you stay-exactly what this net-worth model is built to explore. For a dedicated screen, use the price to rent ratio calculator, then come back here for break-even year and net worth.

Rent vs buy with different credit score rates

Credit score ranges preset an illustrative mortgage rate on the buy path only. Higher rates raise ownership cost and can push break-even later; lower rates help buying. Combine with horizon presets when you search for rent vs buy calculator scenarios. Example: /rent-vs-buy?credit=good&horizon=7 . No credit pull—educational estimates only.

Rent vs buy FAQ

Break-even, stay length, costs included, opportunity cost, and more.

In this calculator, buying “pulls ahead” in the first year when estimated buy net worth is at least as high as rent net worth-shown as the break-even year. That depends on your horizon, down payment, rate, rent, appreciation, investment return, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and closing costs. Change the horizon presets (3, 5, 7, 10 years) and read the break-even label. Educational estimates only-not a market prediction.

Use the comparison horizon and break-even year. If you may move in about 3 years, set the horizon to 3; if you plan to stay 10 years, try 10. The break-even year is the first year in your horizon when buy net worth catches up to rent net worth under your assumptions. If buying never catches up within the horizon, the tool says so. Results are educational estimates only.

The buy path can include principal and interest, property tax, homeowners insurance, HOA, conventional PMI when LTV is above 80%, maintenance as a percent of home value, buy closing costs, and selling costs at the horizon. The rent path includes rent (with growth), renters insurance, and optional other fees. Opportunity cost invests the down payment and buy closing costs on the rent path, plus monthly cash-flow differences.

Opportunity cost is the return you might earn on cash not put into a home-especially the down payment and purchase closing costs. The rent path invests that capital at your assumed return rate. Monthly housing cost differences are also invested by the cheaper path. Returns are assumptions, not forecasts.

Higher assumed home appreciation grows equity on the buy path and can move break-even earlier. Lower or zero appreciation often favors renting when opportunity cost of the down payment is high. Adjust home appreciation and compare horizons-the model is sensitive to this assumption. Past appreciation is not a forecast.

Yes-model a lower down payment (for example 5% or 10% with the preset chips). Conventional loans may include PMI when LTV is above 80%, which raises buy-side housing cost. Also try shorter horizons if you might move soon. First-time buyer programs are not underwritten here; results remain educational estimates only.

Credit score ranges preset an illustrative mortgage rate on the buy path only. A higher rate raises buy housing cost and can delay break-even; a lower rate helps buying. Pick Excellent, Good, Fair, or Poor, or type a quote. There is no credit pull. Optional deep link works with other params, for example /rent-vs-buy?credit=good&horizon=7.

The 5% rule is a rough rule of thumb that annual ownership costs might be around 5% of home price (about 0.5% per month) for a quick compare to rent. It ignores financing details, opportunity cost, appreciation, and your stay length. This calculator is a fuller educational net-worth model with break-even year-not advice and not a substitute for careful assumptions.

It depends on your prices, rent, rate, down payment, and how long you stay. Enter current assumptions (or use horizon and down-payment presets) and compare year-1 monthly costs plus end-of-horizon net worth and break-even year. FinanceFlow does not claim a national answer for “right now.” Educational estimates only.

Yes. For a fair cash comparison at the horizon, the buy path assumes you sell, pay estimated selling costs, and pay off the remaining mortgage. Net proceeds plus any buy-path portfolio become buy net worth. Change the horizon and selling-cost percent to model different scenarios.

No. FinanceFlow is an educational tool only. Outputs use your inputs and state averages where applicable. They are not offers, pre-approvals, tax or investment advice, or professional financial advice. FinanceFlow is not a lender or mortgage broker.

Home affordability estimates reverse the usual payment calculation: starting from income and debt-to-income guidelines, they work out a maximum housing payment, then a maximum loan and home price after taxes, insurance, and other costs. Results are educational planning tools-not pre-approvals or offers to lend.

Amortization is how a fixed-rate mortgage is paid down: early payments are mostly interest, and a growing share goes to principal later. An amortization schedule or graph shows balance, principal, and interest over each year or month of the loan.

Back-end DTI (total debt ratio) adds non-housing debts-such as car loans, student loans, and minimum credit card payments-to housing costs, then divides by gross monthly income. A common educational guideline is about 36%. Some programs allow higher ratios with compensating factors; this calculator’s targets are editable estimates only.

Break-even estimates how many months of payment savings are needed to offset closing costs paid in cash. If costs are rolled into the loan, there may be little or no cash break-even, but the higher balance can raise interest over time. Break-even is an educational estimate based on your inputs-not a guarantee you should refinance.

A cash-out refinance pays off your current mortgage and creates a new, larger loan. The difference (after fees, if applicable) is paid to you in cash. Cash-out increases loan-to-value and may affect PMI eligibility. A rate-and-term refinance keeps cash-out at zero and focuses on rate, term, or loan program changes.

Closing costs are the fees and charges paid when you close on a purchase or refinance. They often include lender origination, appraisal, title, and recording fees. On a refinance you may pay them in cash at closing or roll them into the new loan balance, which increases the principal. Closing costs affect break-even time when you compare payment savings to cash spent upfront.

Combined loan-to-value (CLTV) adds the first mortgage balance and other liens (such as a HELOC draw) and divides by home value. Lenders use CLTV (and related HCLTV, which uses the full credit line) when sizing home equity products. Higher CLTV generally means less equity cushion. FinanceFlow’s HELOC calculator uses an editable educational CLTV guideline (often illustrated around 80%).

A conventional loan is a standard mortgage that is not backed by a government program like FHA, VA, or USDA. It often allows flexible terms and, with less than about 20% down, typically requires PMI. Credit, debt-to-income, and other underwriting rules still apply and vary by lender.

A HELOC credit limit is the approved line amount. You may draw less than the full limit; available credit is limit minus outstanding draw. Educational calculators often estimate a potential limit from home value, existing mortgage balance, and a combined LTV guideline-actual limits depend on underwriting.

Debt-to-income (DTI) compares monthly debt obligations to gross monthly income. Lenders use DTI as one underwriting factor; lower ratios generally mean more room in the budget. FinanceFlow’s affordability calculator uses educational front-end and back-end DTI targets (often illustrated around 28% and 36%) that you can edit-not a lender’s actual limit or a pre-approval.

A down payment is the portion of the home price you pay out of pocket instead of borrowing. A larger down payment lowers the loan amount and can reduce or eliminate PMI on a conventional loan (often when you put at least 20% down). Different loan programs have different minimum down payment rules.

During the draw period (often about 5–10 years), you can usually take advances up to the credit limit. Many HELOCs require interest-only payments on the outstanding balance during this phase. When the draw period ends, new draws typically stop and repayment begins.

Many mortgages include an escrow (or impound) account: each month you pay a share of estimated property taxes and homeowners insurance, and the lender pays those bills when due. Charts may group taxes, insurance, HOA, and PMI as “taxes & fees” or similar. Escrow amounts can be adjusted when taxes or premiums change.

An extra payment is an amount you pay in addition to your regular mortgage payment, typically applied to principal. Paying extra principal can shorten the loan term and reduce total interest. Frequency (monthly, yearly, etc.) and start date affect how much interest you save over time.

FHA loans are insured by the Federal Housing Administration and can help some buyers with lower down payments or different credit profiles. They use FHA mortgage insurance (including MIP concepts), not conventional PMI. Eligibility, fees, and property rules are set by the FHA and the lender-not by this calculator.

Front-end DTI (also called the housing ratio) is your proposed monthly housing cost-typically principal, interest, taxes, insurance, and often HOA and mortgage insurance-divided by gross monthly income. A common educational guideline is about 28%, but real lender guidelines vary by program and borrower profile.

HCLTV (sometimes called high combined LTV or home equity CLTV) treats the entire HELOC credit line as if it were used, plus the first mortgage, divided by home value. It can be higher than CLTV based only on the current draw. Lenders may underwrite to both CLTV and HCLTV limits.

A home equity line of credit (HELOC) lets you borrow against home equity up to a credit limit. Unlike a cash-out refinance, your first mortgage typically stays in place and the HELOC is a second lien. You can draw during a draw period and repay during a repayment period. FinanceFlow’s HELOC calculator models educational credit, payment, and CLTV estimates-not a lender quote.

HOA (homeowners association) fees are regular dues for communities or condominiums that maintain common areas and amenities. They are usually not part of principal and interest but add to your total monthly housing cost. Amounts vary widely and are set by the association, not by your mortgage lender.

Home appreciation is the rise in a property’s market value over time. Rent vs buy and long-term ownership models often apply an annual appreciation rate to estimate future home value and equity. Actual prices can fall as well as rise; any rate you enter is a planning assumption, not a prediction.

Home equity is roughly home value minus outstanding mortgage (and other lien) balances. Lenders use equity and combined loan-to-value when sizing a HELOC or cash-out refinance. Equity changes as you pay down principal or as home value changes.

Home price is the amount you agree to pay for the property. It is the starting point for calculating your down payment, loan amount, and often estimated property taxes and homeowners insurance. Closing costs and prepaid items are usually separate from the home price.

Homeowners insurance protects against covered damage to the home and related risks. Lenders typically require it when you have a mortgage. Monthly amounts in calculators are often based on state averages and home price-they are estimates, not insurer quotes. Actual premiums depend on location, coverage, deductibles, and the property itself.

The interest rate is the percentage a lender charges on your outstanding principal. Mortgage calculators usually use a nominal annual rate and convert it to a monthly rate for the payment formula. Your actual rate depends on credit, loan type, market conditions, and other factors-and may differ from the APR, which includes certain fees.

Interest saved estimates the reduction in total interest when you apply extra principal or pay off early compared with the original amortization. It is an educational estimate based on your inputs, not a guarantee of savings with any specific lender.

An interest-only payment equals the outstanding balance times the periodic interest rate. Principal stays the same unless you pay extra. Many HELOCs use interest-only payments during the draw period, then switch to amortizing payments in repayment. Real HELOC rates are often variable, so interest-only amounts can change over time.

Loan amount is the principal you finance with the mortgage. In a simple purchase scenario it is home price minus down payment, though some loans can include certain financed fees. On a refinance it is often the balance paid off plus any cash-out and costs rolled into the new loan. Your interest charges and amortization schedule are based on this balance over the loan term.

Loan balance is the remaining principal on the mortgage after payments and credits. Amortization charts often plot balance over time as principal is paid down. Extra principal payments reduce the balance faster than the base schedule alone.

Loan term is the length of the repayment schedule, such as 15, 20, 25, or 30 years. Shorter terms usually mean higher monthly principal and interest payments but less total interest over the life of the loan. Longer terms lower the monthly payment but increase total interest if you keep the loan for its full length.

Loan type is the mortgage program used for estimates. Conventional loans are not government-insured and often need PMI below 20% down. FHA, VA, and USDA are government-related programs with different insurance or fee structures and eligibility rules. This calculator uses loan type mainly to decide whether conventional PMI applies; it is not a full underwriting or eligibility check.

Loan-to-value (LTV) compares how much you borrow to the home’s value (often the purchase price on a purchase loan, or current home value on a refinance). For example, a $400,000 home with an $80,000 down payment has a $320,000 loan and an 80% LTV. On a refinance, LTV is typically new loan amount divided by current home value. Higher LTV generally means more risk for the lender and may require PMI on a conventional loan when LTV is above 80%.

Your total monthly payment often includes principal and interest plus property tax, homeowners insurance, HOA, and PMI when applicable. On a refinance, the calculator may also compare your current payment to a new loan payment. Calculator totals are estimates based on your inputs and averages-they are not a lender quote or commitment.

Opportunity cost is the benefit you give up by choosing one use of money over another. In a rent vs buy comparison, cash used for a down payment and purchase closing costs cannot also sit in investments. Rent-path models often invest that capital (and monthly cash-flow differences when renting costs less) at an assumed return rate. Those returns are educational assumptions, not guarantees or forecasts.

Payoff date is when the mortgage would be fully paid based on the schedule and any extra principal. Making extra payments earlier can move the payoff date forward. Actual payoff depends on real payments, rate changes (if any), and lender rules.

Private mortgage insurance (PMI) is commonly required on conventional loans when loan-to-value is above 80% (typically less than 20% down, or higher LTV on a refinance). It protects the lender if you default; it does not protect you. In FinanceFlow’s purchase and refinance calculators, PMI applies only to Conventional loans under that LTV rule. FHA, VA, and USDA use different insurance or fee structures and do not use conventional PMI the same way.

The price-to-rent ratio is home price ÷ (monthly rent × 12). It is a crude educational screen for whether buying looks relatively expensive or cheap versus renting in a market or for a property. Lower ratios are often described as more buy-leaning and higher ratios as more rent-leaning, but cutoffs vary and the ratio ignores mortgage financing, taxes, insurance, maintenance, opportunity cost, appreciation, and how long you stay. FinanceFlow’s price-to-rent calculator computes the ratio and a simple 5% rule proxy; use the rent vs buy calculator for a fuller net-worth comparison. Not financial advice.

Principal is the unpaid balance of your mortgage. Each payment typically covers interest first, then reduces principal. Extra payments applied to principal can shorten the loan and reduce total interest paid over time.

Principal and interest (P&I) is the portion of your monthly mortgage payment that pays interest to the lender and reduces principal. It usually does not include property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA dues, or PMI-those are often listed separately or collected in escrow.

Property taxes are assessed by local governments and vary widely by state, county, and even neighborhood. Mortgage calculators often estimate monthly tax from state averages and home price-these are estimates only, not a tax bill or quote. Your actual taxes depend on local rates, exemptions, and assessments.

Rent growth is the assumed annual increase in rent for a comparable home. In a rent vs buy calculator, higher rent growth increases the long-term cost of renting and can make buying look relatively stronger. Local markets vary widely; the rate is an editable educational assumption, not a lease quote.

A rent vs buy analysis compares the financial outcomes of renting a home versus purchasing one over a chosen number of years. Educational tools often estimate end-of-horizon net worth for each path: buying may build home equity (and assumes a sale with costs in many models), while renting may free up the down payment and closing costs to invest elsewhere. Results depend heavily on assumptions such as rent growth, home appreciation, mortgage rate, and investment returns-and are not financial advice or a loan offer.

After the draw period, the remaining HELOC balance is usually repaid over a set term (often 10–20 years) with fully amortizing principal-and-interest payments. Monthly payments often rise compared with interest-only draw payments because principal is included.

FinanceFlow uses state average housing factors to estimate property taxes, homeowners insurance, and (when relevant) PMI baselines from the home price and selected state. These are educational averages only-not a tax bill, insurance quote, or lender commitment. County, credit, property details, and market conditions can change the real numbers; edit any monthly field to override the estimate.

USDA loans (Rural Development) support eligible buyers in qualifying geographic areas, often with low or no down payment. They do not use conventional PMI and may include a guarantee fee structure instead. Property location and income limits apply.

VA loans are guaranteed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs for eligible service members, veterans, and some surviving spouses. They often allow zero down payment and do not use conventional PMI, though other costs (such as a funding fee in some cases) may apply. Entitlement and eligibility rules are program-specific.